Coffaro's Pizza
  • Home
  • Order ONLINE!
  • Slippery Rock Menu
  • Grove City Menu
  • Bowling
  • Specials
  • Photo Gallery
  • Kids Only
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Policies

**** WE ARE OPEN FOR DELIVERY AND TAKEOUT! ****

Grove City Menu

ORDER ONLINE from GROVE CITY

Please plan to ​wear a mask if you plan to enter our premises to pick up an order. Thank you for your cooperation!


Pizza


Sizes and Prices with Plain Cheese

Personal  |  $4.00 and $.50 per topping
     6 inch, 4 cut
Medium  |  $9.50 and $1.25 per topping
     12 inch, 8 cut
Large  |  $12.25 and $1.75 per topping
     16 inch, 12 cut
Stallion  |  $16.25 and $2.00 per topping
     20 inch, 16 cut

Toppings

Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Bacon, Smoked Ham, Anchovies, Mushrooms, Black Pearl Olives, Fresh Green Peppers, White Onions, Banana Peppers, Pineapple, Extra Cheese
, 
​Cheese  |  $9.50 Medium, $12.25 Large, $16.25 Stallion
Our unique cheese blend gives this pizza its full flavored taste.

The Works  |  $16.25 Medium, $20.00 Large
Italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, smoked ham, mushrooms, black pearl olives, green peppers, white onions, and banana peppers

Hawaiian |  $12.00 Medium, $16.00 Large, $19.00 Stallion
Smoked ham and diced pineapple with our house red sauce.

Deluxe  |  $13.00 Medium, $17.00 Large, $22.00 Stallion
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, white onions, and green peppers.

Meat Lovers  |  $13.00 Medium, $17.00 Large, $22.00 Stallion
Ham, Italian sausage, pepperoni, and bacon.

Veggie  |  $13.00 Medium, $17.00 Large, $22.00 Stallion
White onions, green peppers, olives, mushrooms, and banana peppers.

Chicken  |  $14.00 Medium, $18.00 Large, $22.50 Stallion
You choose your sauce, we top it with chicken.

Steak  |  $14.00 Medium, $18.00 Large, $22.50 Stallion
Steak, onions, and green peppers with ranch.

Chicken Bacon Ranch  |  $14.00 Med, $18.00 Large, $22.50 Stallion 
Diced chicken breast, bacon, and ranch.

Chicken & Spinach  |  $14.00 Med, $18.00 Large, $22.50 Stallion 
Garlic butter sauce topped with garlic, spinach, and chicken.

The Sicilian Pizza

Featuring a thicker Sicilian crust, this pizza comes in a 16 x 16 square 12 cut
Sicilian Cheese |  $15.50
Red sauce, our unique cheese blend, topped with Pecorino Romano.

Sicilian Veggie |  $15.50
Ranch sauce, broccoli, cauliflower, and cheddar cheese.

Breadsticks


Breadsticks |  $4.00
Covered with garlic butter and imported Romano cheese and oregano.  Served with both Coffaro's red sauce and garlic butter.

Our Famous Cheese Breadsticks  |  $6.75
Covered with garlic butter and imported Romano cheese, oregano, and a generous portion of our been of shredded cheese.  Served with both Coffaro's red sauce and garlic butter.

Cinnamon Breadsticks  |  $5.00
Hot dough bread covered with butter, cinnamon, sugar, and smothered with icing.

Calzones and Stomboli


Half  |  12" x 6"      Whole  |  16" x 8"    
* with Ricotta cheese on request
​

Calzone  |  $10.25 Half, $12.25 Whole
Virginia Smoked Ham, Pepperoni,White Onions, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Shredded Cheese, and Coffaro's Red Sauce

Chicken Calzone  |  $10.25 Half, $12.25 Whole
Diced Chicken Breast, White Onions, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Shredded Cheese, and Coffaro's Red Sauce

Steak Calzone  |  $10.25 Half, $12.25 Whole
Steak, White Onions, Green Peppers, Shredded Cheese, and Ranch Dressing

Meatball Calzone  |  $10.25 Half, $12.25 Whole
Meatballs, Mushrooms, White Onions, Shredded Cheese, and Coffaro's Red Sauce

Veggie Calzone  |  $10.25 Half, $12.25 Whole
White Onions, Green Peppers, Black Pearl Olives, Mushrooms Banana Peppers, Shredded Cheese, and Coffaro's Red Sauce

Sausage Calzone  |  $10.25 Half, $12.25 Whole
Italian Sausage, White Onions, Green Peppers, Shredded Cheese, and Coffaro's Red Sauce

Stromboli  |  $10.25 Half, $12.25 Whole
Smoked Ham, Pepperoni, and Shredded Cheese

Drinks


Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Sierra Mist, Dr Pepper, and Water  

2 Liter Bottle |  $2.25

20 Ounce Bottle |  $1.70

Wings


Mild, Hot, BBQ, Montreal, or Rob's Blend

One Dozen Per Order  |  $9.99
Choose one sauce per order of wings and enjoy the savory selections we offer!  We know we'll have something that you love!  Our signature Rob's blend is a mix of BBQ, Mild, and Montreal sauces and a definite customer favorite!
Side Cups  |  $.50
Ranch, Garlic Butter, Blue Cheese, Mild Sauce, Hot Sauce
​

Subs


Half Sub  |  6 inch     Whole Sub  |  12 inch
​

Italian  |  $4.00 Half, $7.50 Whole
Smoked Ham, Cappicola, Salami, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, White Onions, and Italian Dressing

Meatball |  $4.00 Half, $7.50 Whole
Sliced Meatballs, Provolone Cheese, and Coffaro's Red Sauce

Ham and Cheese |  $4.00 Half, $7.50 Whole
Virginia Smoked Ham, Provolone Cheese, White Onions, Sliced Tomato, Lettuce, and Italian Dressing 

Pizza |  $4.00 Half, $7.50 Whole
Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, and Coffaro's Red Sauce

Veggie |  $4.00 Half, $7.50 Whole
Tomatoes, White Onions, Mild Peppers, Black Pearl Olives, Green Peppers, Lettuce, Provolone Cheese, and Italian Dressing

Chicken |  $4.75 Half, $8.50 Whole
Breaded Fried Chicken, Provolone Cheese, Sliced Tomato, Lettuce, and Mayonnaise

Chicken Bacon Ranch |  $4.75 Half, $8.50 Whole
Breaded Fried Chicken, Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Sliced Tomato, Lettuce, and Ranch Dressing

Buffalo Chicken |  $4.75 Half, $8.50 Whole
Breaded Fried Chicken Covered in Buffalo Sauce, Sliced Tomato, Lettuce, and Ranch Dressing

Steak |  $4.75 Half, $8.50 Whole
Steak, White Onions, Green Peppers, Provolone cheese, Lettuce, and Ranch Dressing

Turkey Club |  $4.00 Half, $7.50 Whole
Turkey, Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Sliced Tomatoes, Lettuce, and Ranch Dressing

Sides


Mozzarella Sticks |  $4.75
Six mozzarella sticks served with Coffaro's  red sauce. 

Jalapeno Poppers |  $5.75
Cream cheese stuffed poppers served with a side of ranch.

Breaded Mushrooms |  $4.75
Breaded portabella mushrooms served with Coffaro's red sauce or ranch. 

Zucchini Planks |  $4.75
Battered zucchini planks served with a side of ranch.

Onion Rings |  $3.75
Battered onion rings served with a side of ketchup.

French Fries  |  $2.25
Served with a side of ketchup.

Chicken Tenders |  $5.25
Breaded chicken tenders served with two sides of barbecue sauce.

Salads


Dressings

Italian, Light Italian, Ranch, and Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette
​

Garden Salad  |  $5.00
Green Peppers, White Onions, Tomatoes, Sliced Black Pearl Olives, and Shredded Cheese

Chef Salad  |  $7.50
Smoked Ham, Hard Salami, Pepperoni, Green Peppers, White Onions, Tomatoes, Black Olives, and Shredded Cheese

Chicken Salad  |  $7.50
Chicken, Fries, Onions, Tomatoes, and Pizza Cheese

Steak Salad  |  $7.50
Steak, Fries, Green Peppers, White Onions, Tomatoes, and Shredded Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Salad  |  $7.50
Fried Buffalo Chicken, Fries, White Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, and Shredded Cheese

Grove City Location
116 South Broad Street
Grove City, PA 16127
(724) 458-7900

Hours of Operation
Open Daily
11am - 1am

"We Do It Better"

©Meagan Reed Consulting